logo

Requirement 3: Second Segment Climb


 Background

Climb Gradient

The climb gradient is determined in the regulations:

JAR 25.121 Climb: One-engine-inoperative.
(b) Take-off; landing gear retracted. In the take-off configuration existing at the point of the flight path at which the landing gear is fully retracted, and in the configuration used in JAR 25.111 but without ground effect, the steady gradient of climb may not be less than
      2·4 percent for two-engined aeroplanes,
      2·7 percent for three-engined aeroplanes, and
      3·0 percent for four-engined aeroplanes,
at V2 and with -
(1) The critical engine inoperative, the remaining engines at the take-off power or thrust available at the time the landing gear is fully retracted, determined under JAR 25.111, unless there is a more critical power operating condition existing later along the flight path but before the point where the aeroplane reaches a height of 400 ft above the take-off surface(...); and
(2) The weight equal to the weight existing when the aeroplane's landing gear is fully retracted, determined under JAR 25.111.

In figure 1 the second segment while the takeoff is presented according to JAR.

second segment picture
Figure 1: detail from the takeoff path

 
  next: equations for calculation

 Equations

The second segment is based on the situation with one engine of the aircraft inoperative.
Therefore, the thrust of the remaining engine(s) has to be enough to climb as required. From the equilibrium condition can be got two equations:

Since these equilibrium conditions have to be achieved with one engine inoperative, the required thrust at takeoff with all engines operating has to be higher by a factor N/(N-1). N is the number of engines. The thrust to weight ratio following from the requirement is:

The climb gradient in the equation above is small. Therefore it can be simplified:

 Data

Lift to Drag Ratio

The lift to drag ratio is estimated from the following equation:

The lift coefficient is the takeoff lift coefficient divided by 1.44, because the climb speed is 1.2 times the stall speed.
The drag coefficient consists of five parts:

where the

 
  statistics of aspect ratio
  equation characters - explanation page
  next: calculation of takeoff thrust to weight

 Calculation

With given values of takeoff lift-coefficient, wing aspect ratio and the number of engines it is now possible to calculate the takeoff trust to weight ratio.
In the table are typical start values already entered. The graph is presented in Figure 2.
maximum takeoff lift coefficient
cL,max,TO [ - ]
wing aspect ratio
A [ - ]
number of engines (N) :
 2
 3
 4
result :
takeoff thrust
takeoff weight
    [ - ]

chart for calculated results
Figure 2: chart for calculated results

The takeoff thrust to weight ratio of the aircraft must be above the green line to fulfil the requirement for the second segment condition. (Bear in mind: Thrust means climb rate.)

 Results compared

Takeoff thrust to weight ratio of selected aircraft JANE'S 1995-98
Aircraft Airbus A 300-600BAirbus A 310-300Airbus A 340-300Antonov AN 124Boeing B 737-600Boeing B 777McDonnell Douglas MD11Tupolev TU 204
Takeoff thrust
Takeoff weight   [ - ]
0.308 - 0.3240.290 - 0.3560.220 - 0.2400.2310.3070.292 - 0.3040.299 - 0.3090.341 - 0.413

 
  save the result temporary (Set browser preferences to: "Accept cookies")
  next: missed approach requirement
  back to the start page

© 1999 mail Thomas Perthel, thomas.perthel@gmx.de